What the last 16 years of leadership elections tell us
Two weeks after the midterms, both parties in Congress are spending as much energy on who will lead them as on what they plan to do. On November 10, House Republicans chose Jim Jordan over Steve Scalise as their next leader by a secret-ballot vote of 106 to 73. On December 1, Senate Democrats will decide whether to keep Chuck Schumer or replace him with Chris Van Hollen. Hakeem Jeffries won the race for spea for speaker, and John Thune kept his job as Senate Republican leader by acclamation after rumblings of a challenge.
So is this much competition normal? We looked at every vote the parties held after a general election to fill the four top jobs in Congress, going back to 2010. The four jobs are speaker, House minority leader, Senate majority leader and Senate minority leader.
The data shows it is not unusual for multiple leadership posts to be contested before a new Congress. What has changed recently is how the races end. From 2010 through 2022, no challenger won even a third of the vote. For example, Heath Shuler took 43 votes against Nancy Pelosi after Democrats lost more than 60 House seats in 2010, and Tim Ryan’s 63 votes in 2016 were the most Pelosi had ever lost in a leadership race. Mitch McConnell beat Rick Scott 37 to 10, in the first challenge he had faced in 15 years as leader. These were protest votes, and everyone in the room knew how they would end.
The last two cycles look different. In 2024, Thune beat John Cornyn 29 to 24 to succeed McConnell, so three senators switching sides would have changed the result. The Associated Press called it the first competitive election for Senate Republican leader in three decades. This year, Jordan defeated Steve Scalise, who had been the No. 2 House Republican since 2014 and secured 41 percent of the vote. The Senate Democratic race is the first contested one since 1994, when Tom Daschle beat Chris Dodd by a single vote.
Open seats explain part of this trend, as Thune’s race followed McConnell’s decision to step down, and the House Republican race opened when current House Speaker Mike Johnson chose not to run after his party lost the majority. The Schumer race is harder to explain that way, because every other challenge in this period came after the challenger’s party lost or fell short of expectations. Van Hollen is running against a leader whose party just won the Senate, and Schumer’s allies are making that their main argument.
The conference vote also does not capture every fight, to be fair. Pelosi ran unopposed for speaker in 2018, yet 32 Democrats voted no on the caucus ballot. McCarthy won his nomination easily in 2022 and then needed 15 ballots on the House floor because a small group of far-right holdouts. This month, 15 Republican senators voted to delay Thune’s reelection even though no one ran against him.
None of this is a problem in itself. A secret ballot for leader is one of the few moments when rank-and-file members can tell their leaders what they want. The question is what they ask for. In most recent races, the challenger promised a harder fight against the other party. However, in 2018, nine Democrats in the Problem Solvers Caucus used the same moment differently: they reached an agreement with Pelosi on House rules changes meant to give bipartisan bills a path to the floor. Members in narrow majorities have that leverage every two years, and can use it to make the House and Senate work better.
Related
Sam Zickar
Sam Zickar is Senior Writer at No Labels. He earned a degree in Modern History and International Relations from the University of St Andrews and previously worked in various writing and communications roles in Congress. He lives in the Washington, D.C. area and enjoys exercise and spending time in nature.






You must be logged in to post a comment.